Crimsafe vs. ClearShield – which is better?

• Crimsafe outperforms ClearShield with its patented Screw-Clamp™ system and woven 304-grade stainless steel mesh, delivering superior impact resistance and tamper protection.


• While ClearShield uses a perforated sheet held by a wedge and is generally more affordable upfront, it lacks the durability and strength of Crimsafe’s advanced engineering.


• Crimsafe screens offer better visibility, ventilation, and UV protection compared to ClearShield’s stamped sheet, which blocks more of the view.


• Crimsafe exceeds Australian Standards and is built for long-term durability, even in coastal environments—making it a more valuable investment over time.


• My Security Door specialises in supplying and installing Crimsafe products, providing expert guidance, tailored solutions, and professional installation across Australia.

Crimsafe vs ClearShield: what homeowners need to know

When it comes to securing your home, choosing the right security door and window screens is crucial. There are several options in the Australian market but a common question received is this: is Crimsafe or ClearShield better? Both brands offer security solutions, but which is superior? Well, there are some similarities but also notable differences between Crimsafe and ClearShield. Let’s dive into a comprehensive comparison of Crimsafe vs ClearShield to help you make an informed decision for your home’s safety.

Crimsafe is a well-established Australian company known for its high-quality security screens and doors. They have built a strong reputation for providing robust and reliable security solutions for homes and businesses. Crimsafe’s products are designed to offer maximum protection while maintaining aesthetic appeal and functionality. Crimsafe’s unique technology involves a woven stainless steel mesh that is securely clamped into a heavy-duty aluminium frame. This patented system creates a strong barrier against intruders while still allowing for visibility and airflow. The effectiveness of Crimsafe doors lies in their innovative design and superior materials, making them a popular choice among homeowners seeking top-tier security.

ClearShield is another Australian company that offers security screens and doors. They position themselves as a more affordable alternative to some of the premium brands in the market. ClearShield’s products are designed to provide security and protection while aiming to be cost-effective for consumers. ClearShield uses a different approach in their product design. Instead of woven stainless steel mesh, they utilize a sheet with stamped holes, which creates a distinct look and feel compared to Crimsafe. This look will block a lot more your view compared to crimsafe’s woven mesh

To determine which brand offers the better security solution in the ClearShield vs Crimsafe comparison, let’s assess the two across several key factors:

Crimsafe uses a woven 304 grade stainless steel mesh, which is known for its strength and durability. The mesh is clamped into the frame using a unique screw-clamp system, creating a vice-like grip between the mesh and the frame.

ClearShield uses a perforated stainless steel sheet held in by a wedge. While this design can provide a clean look, it may not offer the same level of strength as Crimsafe’s woven mesh. The method of attaching the sheet to the frame also differs, which can impact overall durability and security.

Crimsafe has developed a unique safety technology that sets it apart in the security door market. Their patented screw-clamp system ensures that the mesh cannot be kicked out of the frame, providing superior protection against forced entry. Additionally, Crimsafe products undergo rigorous testing to meet and exceed Australian Standards for security screens.

ClearShield also meets Australian Standards for security screens. However, the stamped sheet design may not offer the same level of resistance to impact and cutting as Crimsafe’s woven mesh. While ClearShield products can certainly enhance home security, they are without the advanced features of Crimsafe.

Again, there are some similarities here in the ClearShield vs Crimsafe comparison. Both aim to provide security without compromising visibility or aesthetics. Crimsafe’s woven mesh offers superior visibility and airflow, allowing you to enjoy views and breezes while staying protected. The fine mesh also helps to reduce glare and filter out some UV rays.

ClearShield’s perforated sheet design can provide a sleek, modern look. Depending on the size of the perforations, it may offer slightly less visibility compared to Crimsafe’s woven mesh. The choice between the two may come down to personal preference in terms of aesthetics.

Crimsafe products are known for their longevity and low maintenance requirements. The 304 grade stainless steel mesh is highly resistant to corrosion, even in coastal areas. Regular cleaning with soap and water is usually sufficient to keep Crimsafe screens in good condition.

ClearShield also offers durable products, though the stamped sheet design may be more prone to visible damage from impacts and it is worth considering the long-term durability in different environments.

ClearShield is often positioned as a more affordable option compared to Crimsafe. However, it’s important to consider the long-term value and durability when comparing prices. While ClearShield may have a lower upfront cost, Crimsafe’s superior materials and construction could potentially offer better value over time due to increased durability and security.

Crimsafe has established itself as a household name in Australia, largely due to its strong reputation for quality. Their brand recognition and positive word-of-mouth have contributed to their popularity among homeowners. ClearShield, while less well-known, has garnered positive reviews from customers who appreciate its balance of security and affordability. However, it doesn’t have the same level of brand recognition as Crimsafe.

So where do we land on the great Crimsafe vs ClearShield debate? Having analysed both the similarities and differences between Crimsafe and ClearShield, it is Crimsafe that emerges as the superior choice for home security across a range of factors. While ClearShield offers a more affordable option that meets basic security standards, Crimsafe’s advanced technology, superior materials, and proven track record make it the better investment for long-term home protection. Crimsafe’s woven mesh technology, coupled with its unique screw-clamp system, provides unparalleled strength and security. The brand’s commitment to exceeding Australian Standards and its reputation for durability, even in harsh environments, further solidify its position as the top choice. While the initial cost may be higher than ClearShield, the long-term benefits and peace of mind offered by Crimsafe make it worth the investment.

If you’re looking to enhance your home’s security with the best products on the market, Crimsafe is the clear choice. At My Security Door, we specialise in supplying and installing high-quality Crimsafe products to keep your home safe and secure. Our team of experts can guide you through the selection process, ensuring you choose the right Crimsafe solutions for your specific needs. Plus, with our interactive Door Visualiser tool, you can preview how different Crimsafe doors and screens will look on your home, making it easier than ever to design a security solution that fits both your style and safety requirements.

We offer professional installation services to guarantee that your new security screens and doors are fitted correctly for maximum effectiveness. Don’t compromise on your family’s safety. Choose Crimsafe for superior protection, durability, and peace of mind. Contact My Security Door today for a quote and take the first step towards a more secure home.